Skip Navigation
FRC NERRC MSRRC SERRC NCRRC MPRRC WRRC
Personnel for High-Need Students and Schools: Solutions #3 Print E-mail

PERSONNEL FOR HIGH-NEED STUDENTS AND SCHOOLS
SOLUTIONS #3

Studies, Reports, Articles, and Guides
Updated in December 2008

ADDED IN DECEMBER
1) Addressing the Teacher Qualifications Gap:  Exploring the Use of Incentives to Reward Teachers for Tough Assignments.
(2) Advocacy for Equity in Classrooms and Beyond:  New Teachers’
Challenges and Responses.
(3) Gender Will Find a Way:  Exploring How Male Elementary Teachers Make Sense of their Experiences and Responsibilities.
(4) In Search of Wholeness: African American Teachers and Their Culturally Specific Classroom Practices.
(5) Out-of-Field Teaching Persists in Key Academic Courses and
High-Poverty Schools.
(6) Recruiting Quality Teachers in Mathematics, Science, and Special Education for Urban and Rural Schools.




Titles are presented in alphabetical order


A Shared Responsibility: Staffing All High-Poverty, Low-Performing Schools with Effective Teachers and Administrators.  A Framework for Action
Learning First Alliance (LFA), Washington DC. (2005).

"This Framework offers a systemic set of actions for addressing a long-standing problem:  the most vulnerable students -- those in high-poverty, low-performing schools -- are far less likely than their wealthier peers to attend schools with the most qualified teachers, administrators, and other  school staff.  The result of wide-ranging research, decades of collective experience, and sustained  conversation between the leaders and staff of LFA member organizations, the Framework is intended to guide the efforts of LFA organizations and their affiliates as they work together .to ensure all students access to highly effective educators.  In addition, it offers a shared vocabulary and vision to help other stakeholders understand the roles they can play in this important work."
Full text and overview of the 8-Part Framework:
http://www.learningfirst.org/publications/staffing/


Addressing the Teacher Qualifications Gap:  Exploring the Use of Incentives to Reward Teachers for Tough Assignments
Center for American Progress, Washington DC. (2008).
D. Goldhaber.

As the author states, “teachers are, by most any measure, inequitably distributed among students. Poor students are far more likely than their wealthier counterparts to be matched with teachers who have little experience, graduated from less-selective colleges, and possess fewer credentials. It is not surprising that inequities exist in the distribution of teachers across the nation’s classroom. . . . Yet most school systems utilize a single-salary-schedule pay structure that determines a teacher’s salary by his or her degree and experience alone without considering, for instance, the desirability of the teaching position. . . . This report builds on what we do know and combines it with labor-economic theory and an assessment of the politics associated with teacher-equity reforms to make four recommendations designed to help address teacher equity.”
Full text: 
http://www.americanprogress.org/issues/2008/11/teacher_qualification_gap.html


Advocacy for Equity in Classrooms and Beyond:  New Teachers’ Challenges and Responses
Teachers College Record, Columbia University, New York City. (2007).
S. Z. Athanases & L. C. De Oliveira

The authors “sought to understand how graduates of one teacher credential program appear prepared to advocate for educational equity in their new jobs by asking three questions: (a) What challenges do new teachers identify in classes and schools that require advocacy for some youth? (b) In what ways do they respond to such challenges? and (c) What enables these acts of advocacy? . . . Teachers reported actions to address equity in a range of sites, with the classroom as the core site for teachers’ advocacy work.  In complex narratives, teachers reported trying to meet learning needs of diverse students.  English language learners’ needs especially prompted acts of advocacy in and beyond the classroom.  These included instructional tailoring, out-of-class tutorials, hunts for better texts and tests, a library field trip, creation of a culture/computer club, heightened parent contacts, and launching of a bilingual parent group.  Teachers’ acts of advocacy shared four crosscutting themes -- a goal of equitable access to resources and support, convictions about equity, interceding on behalf of students in need, and engaging co-advocates.”
Abstract (full text for purchase):
http://www.tcrecord.org/Content.asp?ContentID=14535


African American Male Teachers in Public Schools:
An Examination of Three Urban School Districts
Teachers College Record. (2006).  C. W. Lewis.
Teachers College, Columbia University, New York City

“Currently, African American students constitute approximately 20% of the public school population, while African American male teachers constitute 1% of the teaching force. In this article, the author presents the findings of a study that examined the disproportionate number of African American male teachers in America's K–12 public schools.  More specifically, the researcher surveyed 147 African American male teachers in three urban school districts in Louisiana to better understand what strategies school districts could implement to increase the presence of African American male teachers. The recommendations are presented in this article.”
Abstract (full text for purchase or through online membership):
http://www.tcrecord.org/Content.asp?ContentID=12308


Aligning Potential and Opportunity: Recruiting Non-Traditional Teacher Candidates
Through Specialized Urban Teacher Education

Institute for Democracy, Education, and Access, University of California,
Los Angeles. (2005).  K. B. Lyons & K. H. Quartz

“This paper reports on a cross-sectional analysis of survey data collected on over three hundred preservice teachers enrolled in a specialized teacher education program focused on the preparation of teachers for high-poverty urban schools. Initial analyses indicate that the background characteristics of individuals attracted to the specialized program and their reasons for entering the profession differ from those of pre-service teachers in the population at large.  Program entrants tend to be motivated by activist ideals, expressing high levels of initial commitment to teaching and to furthering social justice through education.  Laying the groundwork for comparison studies, the author argues that the specialized recruitment of preservice teachers may combine with specialized teacher preparation to increase the retention of educators in high-poverty, hard-to staff schools.”
Full text:  http://idea.gseis.ucla.edu/publications/utec/wp/03.html


Alternative Certification: A Review of Theory and Research
North Central Educational Laboratory. (2002).  Learning Point Associates,
Naperville, Illinois. R. Legler.

The first section of this report describes the diverging views on alternative certification.  “The next section of this paper reviews the background and history of alternative certification programs, and outlines the structures and components of many of these approaches to teacher certification. Following this, a review of the research on the effectiveness of alternative certification programs is presented and discussed.  The paper concludes with recommendations about the structure and content that should be included in quality alternative certification programs.”
Full text of report:
http://www.ncrel.org/policy/pubs/html/altcert/index.html


America’s Challenge: Effective Teachers for At-Risk Schools and Students
National Comprehensive Center for Teacher Quality, Learning Point Associates, Washington DC. (2007).  C. A. Dwyer (Ed.)

 “The main body of this report consists of six chapters related to the main streams of activity engaged in by the Center during the past two years: (a) a research analysis of the links between good teaching and student learning . . . (b) an action-oriented review and analysis of gaps in the preparation of effective teachers for at-risk students, including those with disabilities . . . (c) an analysis of the complexity of the issues involved in improving teaching for special education students . . . (d) a review of State policies and strategies that currently address the challenge of equitable distribution of effective teachers . . . (e) promising new and emerging teacher recruitment and retention strategies that States and districts are using to improve teacher quality in at-risk and hard-to-staff subject areas; and (f) results from a nationally representative sample of first-year teachers.”
Full text:  http://www.ncctq.org/publications/NCCTQBiennialReport.php


Assessment of Diversity in America’s Teaching Force: A Call to Action

National Collaborative on Diversity in the Teaching Force, Washington DC. (2004).

“The necessity for teacher diversity is often overlooked rather than accepted as central to school reform.  High-stakes tests impede efforts to expand the pool of prospective teachers of color.  And the logistics of the No Child Left Behind Act continue to create significant barriers to recruiting teachers of color.  These are some of the conclusions from an analysis on teacher diversity prepared by the National Collaborative on Diversity in the Teaching Force.  In its report, the Collaborative examined the relationship between educational achievement and teacher diversity, and found that increasing the percentage of teachers of color in classrooms is connected directly to closing the achievement gap of students.”
News release – Click on second paragraph for full text:
http://www.nea.org/newsreleases/2004/nr041109.html


Attracting, Developing, and Retaining Effective Teachers
National Council for Teacher Quality, Washington DC. (2004).
With the U.S. Department of Education’s International Affairs Office
as part of an international project with the Organization for Economic
Cooperation and Development, Paris, France.

“This report presents a balanced picture of the debate on teacher quality in the U.S. and focuses on the aspects of teacher policy dealing with attracting, recruiting, developing and retaining effective teachers by synthesizing relevant research, identifying innovative and successful policy practices, facilitating exchanges of lessons among countries and identifying policy options.  Fully vetted by the National Center for Education Statistics, no other publication includes comprehensive data about such a diverse group of topics.  Covering issues from teaching requirements to retirement, this is a large 25-nation study and is the first of its kind on teacher issues.”
Full text – Scroll down by year:  http://www.nctq.org/p/publications/reports.jsp


Attracting Well Qualified Teachers to Struggling Schools.
American Educator. (2002).  American Federation of Teachers, Washington DC. 
C. D. Prince.

“Can school superintendents and union representatives work together to design fair, effective strategies to ensure that the students with the greatest needs are assigned especially well-qualified teachers?  This article analyzes the enormous complexity of this issue, including the impact of teacher quality on student achievement, the evidence that teachers regularly migrate out of low-performing schools, and the potential solution that lies in offering incentives to well-qualified teachers who commit to work in struggling schools.”  The author identifies one problem as “equal pay for unequal work,” reviews evidence that monetary incentives (along with improved conditions) can help, and describes examples.
Full text:
http://www.aft.org/pubs-reports/american_educator/winter2002/AttractingTeachers.html


Better Teachers, Better Preschools:
Student Achievement Linked to Teacher Qualifications

NIEER Policy Brief, National Institute for Early Education Research, Rutgers,
The State University of New Jersey. (2004).  W. S. Barnett.

“Research has linked early learning and development to the educational qualifications of teachers.  The most effective preschool teachers – those with at least a four-year college degree and specialized training in early childhood – have more responsive interactions with children, provide richer language and cognitive experiences, and are less authoritarian. . . . This brief presents current educational requirements for preschool teachers, reviews evidence on the importance of teacher qualifications, and offers policy recommendations.”
Summary and click for full text:
http://nieer.org/docs/index.php?DocID=62


Career Pathways of Urban Teachers in Los Angeles: Who Stays, Who Leaves, and Who Shifts Into Other Education Work?
Institute for Democracy, Education, and Access, University of California,
Los Angeles. (2005).  L. Anderson & B. Olsen.

“This paper reports on a year-long mixed methods study aimed at better understanding the motives, processes and consequences of urban teachers’ decisions to change roles within education.  This study has involved charting Center X teacher education program graduates’ career pathways, analyzing year-to-year interval data, and conducting survey research on a sub-sample of shifters – graduates who reported changing roles within education at least once since they first entered teaching.  Preliminary findings indicate the richness and variety of post-graduate pathways in urban education and raise important questions about how to conceptualize careers in education, how to support teachers and education professionals over the course of their careers, and how to frame retention.”
Full text:   http://idea.gseis.ucla.edu/publications/utec/wp/09.html
Also see a related paper (“The Fragility of Urban Teaching”):
http://idea.gseis.ucla.edu/publications/utec/wp/01.html
And see “Careers in Motion: A Longitudinal Retention Study of Role Changing
Patterns Among Urban Educators”

http://idea.gseis.ucla.edu/publications/utec/wp/04.html


Child and Adolescent Development Research and Teacher Education
Summary of Roundtable Meetings Sponsored by the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development and the National Council for the Accreditation of Teacher Education, Washington DC. (2005 and 2006).

“The National Institute of Child Health and Human Development and the National Council for Accreditation of Teacher Education collaborated to produce a summary of two roundtable discussions on the critical relevance of child and adolescent development research to teacher preparation practices. . . . The following are highlighted in this summary:  (a) the state of practice in teacher education, highlighting the ways in which child and adolescent development research is currently integrated into teacher preparation curricula; (b) ongoing investigations of child and adolescent development from selected research studies, and how aspects of these studies may be applicable to teacher preparation; (c) issues and challenges in translating research to practice; and (d) applications and action steps for linking child development research with teacher preparation practices.”
Full text: http://www.nichd.nih.gov/publications/pubs_details.cfm?from=&pubs_id=5684


Coping with Teacher Shortages: A Resource Guide
The Annie E. Casey Foundation, Baltimore, Maryland. (2002).
P. Murphy & E. Novak.

“This guide was prepared by researchers at the University of San Francisco for the Casey Foundation to assist education leaders in their effort to deal with the problem of teacher shortages.  It provides insights to help educators think strategically about the issues affecting the supply of teachers and gives practical tips to help them develop a plan of action to address those challenges.  Following a conceptual overview section, the guide then presents information on 25 specific programs all designed to address at least one particular element of the teacher shortage problem.”  The report provides information on external assessments of a few programs, and provides a chart of all 25 in terms of: (a) number of applicants; (b) quality of applicants; (c) labor marketing and salaries; (d) education cost/debt; (e) housing; (f) barriers to entry; (g) red tape; (h) subject shortages; (i) hard-to-recruit-for schools; and (j) retention.  Profiles of each program are included.
Full text:
http://www.aecf.org/KnowledgeCenter/SearchResults.aspx?keywords=
Coping%20with%20Teacher%20Shortages&source=topsearchKC



Courses of Action:
A Qualitative Investigation of Urban Teacher Retention and Career Development

Institute for Democracy, Education, and Access, University of California,
Los Angeles. (2004).  B. Olsen & L. Anderson

“This paper presents findings from a study investigating relationships among the reasons for entry, preparation experiences, workplace conditions, and future career plans of fifteen UCLA Teacher Education Program graduates working in urban elementary schools in Los Angeles.   More specifically, the analysis examines why these early career teachers stay in or consider leaving the urban schools in which they are teaching. The findings highlight the need to reconceptualize notions of teacher retention in order to better acknowledge and support the development of deep, varied, successful careers in the field of urban education.”
Full text:   http://idea.gseis.ucla.edu/publications/utec/reports/rrs03.html


Critical Need for Bilingual Education Teachers: 
The Potentiality of Normalistas and Paraprofessionals.

Bilingual Research Journal, (2002).  National Association for Bilingual Education
and Southwest Center for Education Equity and Language Diversity,
Arizona State University, Tempe.   B. B. Flores, S. Keehn, & B. Perez.

“Case study methodology was employed to explore the potentiality of Mexican teachers (normalistas) and paraprofessionals as prospective bilingual education teachers.  The evidence of this study suggests that both normalistas and paraprofessionals offer fertile ground for bilingual teachers.  The evidence further suggests that careful selection of the potential candidates is crucial.  Moreover, the teacher preparation program must creatively examine and implement a program of study that meets the needs of the target group.  The findings also reveal that, as the participants move through teacher preparation courses, members of both cohorts are willing to challenge old notions formerly held. . . . While drawing on the richness and merits of the Mexican system, these immigrants are open to seeing merit in U.S. educational methods. Conversely, the paraprofessionals are beginning to question the deficit model pervasive in many of the schools in which they have worked and to take a different stance toward authority figures.”
Full text:   http://brj.asu.edu/content/vol26_no3/abstracts.html


Doing What Counts: Design Principles for a Study on Teacher Incentives
MDRC, New York City. (2006).
J. C. Snipes, J. C. Quint, S. Rappaport, & L. S. Schofield.

The Doing What Counts project is a collaborative effort of the Laboratory for Student Success at Temple University and MDRC to design and execute rigorous research that will develop reliable evidence about the use of financial and non-financial incentives to recruit and retain high-quality teachers for underperforming schools — with the ultimate goal of improving student achievement.  This paper reviews the research on teacher quality and the use of incentives, describes incentive programs in seven urban school districts, and outlines design principles for an exploratory study on the use of incentives.”
Abstract and full text - Click at the left:
http://www.mdrc.org/publications/421/abstract.html


Education for the Community:
Exploring the Culturally Relevant Practices of Black Male Teachers

Teachers College Record. (2006).  Teachers College, Columbia University,
New York City.   M. Lynn.

“Black men have remained largely absent from the educational discourse on teachers and teaching. Even more important, their perspectives have not been fully considered in the debates over what constitutes culturally relevant classroom practice.  In this article, portraits of the teaching lives of three Black men who worked as full-time teachers in urban schools in California are drawn. The portraits outline the teachers’ entrée into teaching, their views on pedagogy, and their culturally and racially sensitive pedagogical practice.”
Abstract (full text by membership or purchase):
http://www.tcrecord.org/Content.asp?ContentID=12851



Eight Questions on Teacher Preparation:  What Does the Research Say?
Education Commission of the States, Denver, Colorado. (2003).
Summarized by the National Evaluation and Technical Assistance Center for the
Education of Children and Youth Who are Neglected, Delinquent, or At Risk

“This report outlines effective strategies for educating and training teachers.  The report reviews the large body of research on teacher preparation from 92 studies and is helpful for policymakers, teachers and educators, and others who would like to know more about teacher preparation. . . . Each question is accompanied by a related subquestion, and the report includes a detailed description of the findings and policy implications for each of the eight questions.  The overall conclusion was that research on teacher preparation does provide some guidance for policymakers and others in the areas of coursework, field experience, and alternative approaches to teacher preparation.  The report also offers several recommendations for improving the amount and quality of the research.
Full text:  http://www.neglected-delinquent.org/nd/resources/articles/articlesummary200507b.asp


Excellence in the Classroom
The Future of Children. (2007).  The Woodrow School of Public and International Affairs at Princeton University and The Brookings Institution, Washington DC.

“Improving the quality of teachers is . . . crucial to efforts to raise student achievement and narrow achievement gaps. But schools with high concentrations of black students, Hispanic students, and students in poverty have serious problems in recruiting and retaining effective teachers. . . . Researchers have established that carefully designed public policies can strengthen teacher quality. The articles in this volume explore key tools available to policymakers to do just that — from changes in the way teachers are certified, to investments in professional development, to wage policies, to financial and other incentives, to policies that affect unions and collective bargaining.  The volume also examines the special challenges facing rural and urban districts and synthesizes relevant experiences from other developed and developing nations.”
Full text of eleven articles plus executive summary and policy brief:
http://www.futureofchildren.org/pubs-info2825/pubs-info_show.htm?doc_id=468970


Fix It and They Might Stay:
School Facility Quality and Teacher Retention in Washington DC.  

Teachers College Record, Columbia University, New York City. (2005).  
J. Buckley, M. Schneider, & Y. Shang.

“There is a large empirical literature that investigates why teachers quit and how they might be induced to stay.  Here (the authors) build upon this literature by suggesting another important factor in the teacher decision to stay or leave -- the quality of school facilities.  (They) investigate the importance of facility quality using data from a survey of K-12 public school teachers in Washington DC.”
Abstract (full text by purchase or by online membership):
http://www.tcrecord.org/Content.asp?ContentId=11852


Gender Will Find a Way:  Exploring How Male Elementary Teachers Make Sense of their Experiences and Responsibilities
Contemporary Issues in Early Childhood, United Kingdom. (2006).
C. Ashcraft & B. Sevier.

“In recent years, public discussions over the socialization of boys have increased dramatically. . . . The authors contend that simply increasing male representation is not enough.  Drawing from interviews with fourteen male elementary teachers, they explore how these teachers understood and talked about their experiences and responsibilities as male teachers. . . . (The authors) identify implications for teacher education, professional development, public rhetoric and debate, and future efforts to recruit and incorporate more male teachers.”
Full text:
http://www.wwwords.co.uk/ciec/content/pdfs/7/issue7_2.asp#4


Impact of Training and Education for Caregivers of Infants and Toddlers

National Center for Children in Poverty, Mailman Center for Public Health,
Columbia University, New York City. (2005)
J. L. Kreader, D. Ferguson, & S. Lawrence.

“What approaches to caregiver training and education are the most likely to improve the quality of care for children under age 3 in family child care homes and centers?  To help answer to this question, this brief describes research findings on a small number of training initiatives targeting infant and toddler caregivers where quality was observed before and after training.  While it is too soon to draw firm generalizations from this young and scattered body of  research, findings from these studies raise pertinent considerations for policymakers.”
Full text – Click at the right: 
http://www.childcareresearch.org/location/ccrca6874


Improving Instruction Through Effective Teacher Evaluation:
Options for States and Districts

National Comprehensive Center for Teacher Quality, Washington DC. (2008).
C.  Mathers & M. Oliva with S. W. M. Laine.

“This brief discusses the measures used in teacher evaluation and focuses on their strengths, limitations, and current use. It underscores aspects of evaluation policies currently aligned with best practices and illuminates areas in which policymakers can improve evaluation rules, regulations, and implementation — thereby improving teacher instruction and student performance.”
Full text – Scroll down:
http://www.tqsource.org/tqbrief.php


Improving the Distribution of Teachers in Low-Performing High Schools
Alliance for Excellent Education, Washington DC. (2008).

A major premise of this Policy Brief is that “understanding the dynamics of the teacher labor market is critical for policymakers considering ways to improve teacher distribution.  Closing the distribution gap is not as simple as forcing good teachers into low-performing high schools, though some districts have contemplated forced transfers when other incentives have failed to work.  Instead, the main policy task is to leverage incentives attuned to the current labor market; to produce more and better candidates; to recruit teachers into struggling high schools; and to keep them there long enough to make a difference.  Salary, distance from home, and working conditions are a few of the many labor market realities that affect a person’s decision of whether or not to become a teacher, where to work, and how long to stay.” The remainder of the paper discusses strategies and solutions, with some examples of States or districts where strategies have been implemented.
Full text – Scroll down:
http://www.all4ed.org/publication_material/issue_policy_briefs


In Search of Our Mothers’ Gardens: 
Black Women Teachers and Professional Socialization

Teachers College Record. (2008).  Teachers College, Columbia University,
New York City.  A. Dixson & J. E. Dingus.

“This article integrates findings from two separate studies on Black women teachers.  It examines reasons underlying the professional entry of Black women into teaching and uses a Black feminist/womanist framework to examine how the nexus of race, gender, and class impacts Black women’s decisions to enter teaching while also informing their teaching missions.  The article is situated in novelist Alice Walker’s metaphorical gardens to examine the intergenerational connections of Black women teachers to teaching. . . . (The authors) argue that educational research, in keeping with a policy focus on quality instruction, must continue to examine the practices of Black women teachers, who have effective pedagogical practices with underserved populations.  In doing so, (they) caution against operationalizing such pedagogical practices in ways that trivialize their teaching practices and render them invisible.  Furthermore, (they) encourage researchers to examine how teacher education can make explicit the experiences, knowledge, wisdom and spiritual aspects of Black women’s pedagogical practices.  Research must also consider the ways in which Black women teachers draw on intergenerational networks in their teaching practices and how these relate to their conceptualizations of their roles as teachers.”
Abstract (full text by membership or purchase):
http://www.tcrecord.org/Content.asp?ContentID=14630


In Search of Wholeness: African American Teachers and Their Culturally Specific Classroom Practices
Palgrave MacMillan, New York City. (2002).  J. J. Irvine (Ed.).

This book “is a theoretical and practice-oriented treatment of how culture and race influence African American teachers. This collection of essays, edited by Jacqueline Jordan Irvine, assumes that teachers cannot become fully functional persons and competent professionals if their cultural selves remain denied, hidden, and unexplored.  Part one reviews the literature related to teachers’ race and culture.  Part two includes research studies about teachers confronting issues of culture and race in their personal and professional lives.  The final chapter focuses on the responses of three of the teachers whose stories are portrayed in the book.  . . . Other topics explored include: (a) multicultural professional development for African American teachers, (b) African American teachers’ perceptions of their professional roles and practices, (c) a comparison of effective black and white teachers of African American students, (d) the development of teacher efficacy of an African American middle school teacher, (e) the professional development journey of an effective African American elementary school teacher, (f) seizing hope through culturally responsive praxis, and (g) collective stories on culturally specific pedagogy.”
For purchase:  http://us.macmillan.com/insearchofwholeness


Innovations in Teacher Education: A Social Constructivist Approach

State University of New York Press, Albany. (2006).  C. Beck & C. Kosnick

The authors show that constructivist teaching and structured classroom lessons are not incompatible; explain how teacher preparation can incorporate constructivist theory and practice; and highlight such preservice programs as those at the Bank Street College of Education, Edith Cowan University, Mills College, New York University, Ontario Institute for Studies in Education, Stanford University, and Teachers College at Columbia University.
For purchase:
http://www.sunypress.edu/details.asp?id=61259


Minority Teacher Recruitment, Development, and Retention
The Education Alliance at Brown University, Providence, Rhode Island. (2004).
J. Torres, J. Santos, N L. Peck, & L. Cortes.

“This is a comprehensive review of recent research on the contributions of diverse teachers to the education of both white and minority students. T he report points to major obstacles faced by minorities in the teacher preparation pipeline from high school into the teaching profession, and provides useful examples of effective supports that can motivate and prepare minorities to succeed in high school, college, and the classroom.  This is a useful resource for both educators and researchers, with rich examples of effective programs and practices, and an extensive bibliography.”
Full text:   http://www.alliance.brown.edu/pubs/minority_teacher/


No Common Denominator:  The Preparation of Elementary Teachers in
Mathematics by America’s Education Schools

National Council on Teacher Quality, Washington DC. (2008).
J. Greenbert & K. Walsh

“American students' chronically poor performance in mathematics on international tests may begin in the earliest grades, handicapped by the weak knowledge of mathematics of their own elementary teachers. NCTQ looks at the quality of preparation provided by a representative sampling of institutions in nearly every state.  NCTQ also provides a test developed by leading mathematicians which assesses for the knowledge that elementary teachers should acquire during their preparation.  Imagine the implications of an elementary teaching force being able to pass this test.”
Full text, executive summary, test and answer key:   
http://www.nctq.org/p/publications/reports.jsp


Out-of-Field Teaching Persists in Key Academic Courses and High-Poverty Schools
The Education Trust, Washington DC. (2008).
With analysis by R. M. Ingersoll.

“The School and Staffing Survey (SASS) data show that in secondary schools across the country, far too many teachers have neither an academic major nor State certification in the subjects they teach.  The problem of out-of-field teaching is especially prevalent in middle grades (grades 5-8) and in mathematics classes. What’s worse, the highest rates of out-of-field teaching appear in high-poverty and high-minority schools, the very schools where students desperately need good teachers. . . . In crafting the No Child Left Behind Act, Congress tried to direct more attention and energy to this problem by requiring ‘highly qualified’ teachers in all core academic classes and by asking district and State leaders to attest that low-income and minority students are not taught disproportionately by out-of-field teachers. It seems clear from the data, however, that needed changes are not occurring rapidly enough to make a difference in student achievement.  This report provides an overview of available data, profiles some promising approaches, and suggests questions state and district leaders should be able to answer.”
Press release and click for full text
http://www2.edtrust.org/EdTrust/Press+Room/CoreProblems.htm


Powerful Teacher Education: Lessons From Exemplary Programs
Jossey-Bass Publishers, San Francisco, California. (2006).  L. Darling-Hammond

This book “describes the strategies, goals, content, and processes of seven highly successful and long-standing teacher education programs -- Alverno College, Bank Street College, Trinity University, University of California, Berkeley, University of Southern Maine, University of Virginia, and Wheelock College. All these colleges and universities have succeeded in preparing teachers to teach diverse learners to achieve high levels of performance and understanding.  In discussing the common features of these programs, Linda Darling-Hammond shows what outstanding teacher education models do and how they do it, and what their graduates accomplish as a result.  Powerful Teacher Education also examines the policies, organizational features, resources, and relationships that have enabled these programs to succeed.”
For purchase:
http://www.josseybass.com/WileyCDA/WileyTitle/productCd-0787972738.html


Preparing All Education Personnel to Address Barriers to Learning and Teaching
Center for Mental Health in Schools, University of California, Los Angeles (2008).

“The next decade must mark a turning point for how schools and communities address the many barriers to learning experienced by children and youth. Needed in particular are initiatives to transform how schools work to prevent and ameliorate these barriers which lead to so many students being designated as learning, behavior, and emotional problems. . . . With a view to clarifying implications for policy and practice, this report represents the Center’s first efforts to explore the frequently asked question: How are preservice preparation programs for teachers, support staff, and administrators focusing on addressing barriers to learning and teaching?  (The report begins) by reiterating the case for why it is essential to fundamentally and systemically transform how schools (working with families and communities) address barriers to learning and teaching.  This is followed by discussion of the general challenges confronting personnel development for education.  Then, to anchor the discussion in the reality of current personnel preparation programs, (the report) synthesizes findings gleaned from a Leadership Institute the Center conducted in June 2008 for representatives from university departments of education.  Participants at the Institute were presented an overview of the need to enhance personnel preparation for addressing barriers to learning and teaching, and then they discussed and provided input on (a) implications for school improvement and thus for pre- and inservice personnel preparation programs and (b) how personnel preparation programs can deal with such implications.  Throughout, the report offers major implications for transforming personnel preparation for teachers, student support staff, administrators, and other stakeholders involved in addressing barriers to learning and teaching.”
Full text:
http://smhp.psych.ucla.edu/pdfdocs/preparingall.pdf
Center’s home page -- See additional resources:
http://smhp.psych.ucla.edu


Preparing to Stay:
Examining the Effects of Specialized Preparation on Urban Teacher Retention

Institute for Democracy, Education, and Access,
University of California, Los Angeles. (2005).  L. B. Lyons

“Using data obtained as part of an on-going longitudinal study of graduates of a specialized urban teacher education program, this paper reports on the projected retention rates of beginning, specially-prepared teachers in high-poverty schools and compares them with the anticipated retention rates of beginning teachers from a national sample.  Although only a first step in a broader, systematic analysis of the effect of specialized teacher preparation on retention, findings speak to the important role beginning teacher support and induction play in the effort to retain teachers in high-poverty schools and lay the groundwork for future comparative studies.”  The program studied in this article is an intensive, two-year program that specifically prepares participants for careers in urban, high poverty schools and takes a decidedly social justice focus to teaching and teacher education.”
Full text:  http://idea.gseis.ucla.edu/publications/utec/wp/08.html


Raising Student Achievement Through the Equitable Distribution of Teachers
National Comprehensive Center for Teacher Quality, Washington DC. (2006).
A Webcast by M. R. Islas, L. Murray, & D. Hirsh.  J. Luczak, Moderator.

On March 30, 2006, the National Comprehensive Center for Teacher Quality hosted an interactive webcast that explored the topic of teacher distribution.  Three experts representing research, policy, and practice perspectives explored promising solutions to the challenges associated with the equitable distribution of teachers.   A recording of the live webcast, a slide presentation, and posted discussions are available at the website.
Recording of the webcast and related information:
http://www.ncctq.org/webcasts/equitable/
Also see the webcast on Teacher Turnover in At-Risk Schools:
http://www.ncctq.org/webcasts/turnover/


Readings from the 2006 Aspen-OECD Conference on Learning From Abroad
Aspen Institute, Washington DC. (2006). 

“Other nations face the same challenges as U.S. school systems, but do better at attracting, supporting and retaining effective teachers.  What can the U.S. learn from abroad?  These Aspen reports, which were compiled for a 2006 joint seminar co-sponsored by the Aspen Institute and the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) based in Paris, provide lessons for U.S. policymakers and practitioners.”
Full texts:
http://www.aspeninstitute.org/site/c.huLWJeMRKpH/b.3416277/k.AF39/
Readings_from_2006_AspenOECD_Conference_on_Learning_from_Abroad.htm

Country profiles and cross-country comparison chart:
http://www.aspeninstitute.org/site/c.huLWJeMRKpH/b.2282621/k.F018/
Country_Profiles_and_CrossCountry_Comparison_Chart.htm

Also see OECD’s Final Report: Teachers Matter   – Extensive overview, chapter summaries, and purchase information:
http://www.oecd.org/document/52/0,2340,en_2649_37455_34991988_1_1_1_37455,00.html


Recruiting and Retaining Teachers for Hard-to-Staff Schools
Center for Teaching Quality, National Governors Association,
Washington DC. (2005).  B. Berry & E. Hirsch

 “Although States have maintained a focus on recruiting and retaining teachers, many schools and districts  still face daunting challenges in ensuring a qualified and competent teaching corps. It is particularly  difficult for schools considered hard to staff—those with high concentrations of low-performing, low-income students; high teacher turnover; and relatively high percentages of teachers who are less than fully  certified. States are experimenting with numerous strategies for recruiting and retaining teachers, and some  of them are trying particularly to help hard-to-staff schools.”  This Issue Brief offers recommendations and reviews some practices that appear to be promising.
Full text:
http://www.nga.org/portal/site/nga/menuitem.9123e83a1f6786440ddcbeeb501010a0/?vgnextoid=
24462d3fe9e27010VgnVCM1000001a01010aRCRD



Recruiting Male Teachers
Beyond the Journal: Young Children on the Web. (2002).
National Association for the Education of Young Children, Washington DC.

“A major barrier to men becoming early childhood teachers is the pervasive belief in our society and in our profession that men are less able to care for and educate young children than are women.  To counter this belief and recruit more men to work with young children will take a comprehensive and systematic effort. . . . This article describes what school administrators, teacher educators, middle and  high school educators can do to support men in entering the field.”
Full text:  http://www.journal.naeyc.org/btj/200211/


Recruiting Quality Teachers in Mathematics, Science, and Special Education for Urban and Rural Schools
National Comprehensive Center for Teacher Quality, Learning Point Associates, Washington DC. (2007).

 “This publication focuses on six strategies for recruiting highly qualified teachers in mathematics, science, and special education: (a) grow-your-own strategies, (b) partnerships with institutions of higher education to create alternative licensure routes, (c) financial incentives, (d) streamlined hiring processes, (e) improved working conditions and support, and (f) approaches and policies to stem the tide of attrition and migration.”
Full text:
http://www.tqsource.org/recruitQuality.php


Recruitment and Retention Materials: Culturally and Linguistically Diverse Populations
American Speech-Language-Hearing Association, Rockville, Maryland.

“In 2001, the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association established a three-year Focused Initiative on Culturally and Linguistically Diverse Populations.  Between 2001 and 2003, two outcomes were identified as targets. One of those outcomes was an increase in the number of ASHA members from racial/ethnic minority populations.”   Materials available at this site include a compendium of exemplary practices by colleges and universities in the recruitment, retention, and career transition of Communication Sciences and Disorders professionals; a review of literature; and other information.
Full texts:   http://www.asha.org/about/leadership-projects/multicultural/recruit/


Redesigning the Preparation of General and Special Education Teachers:
Collaboration Within a Schoolwide System of Support.

Testimony of Dr. Michael L. Hardman, Dean-Designate, College of Education,
University of Utah, Salt Lake City,
Before the Committee on Education and Labor,
Subcommittee on Early Childhood, Elementary and Secondary Education,
U.S. House of Representatives. (March 29, 2007).

In this testimony, Dr. Hardman points out that “in many parts of this country, general and special education teachers are still being prepared in total isolation of one another. . . . These isolated teacher preparation programs continue although more than 96% of all students with disabilities spend at least a portion of their school day side-by-side with their peers who are not disabled in an inclusive classroom setting. . . . The University of Utah is presently undertaking a university-wide redesign of teacher education at every level from early childhood to secondary education. . . . Our program design is based on three critical elements: (a) universal design for learning within the framework of a three-tier model for evidence-based instruction that provides teachers with the tools for data-based decisions; (b) an extensive professional core of knowledge and skills that is required for every general and special education teacher attending the university; and (c) university courses directly linked to continuous field experiences in inclusive classrooms and schools. . . . Teacher candidates are provided with the progress monitoring tools that are needed for data-based decisions in terms of selecting, using, and adapting instruction.  Data are used to guide instruction, appropriate intervention and practice, parent involvement, and other research-based practices.” These practices as implemented at the University of Utah are discussed in the testimony.
Full text: 
http://edworkforce.house.gov/testimony/032907MichaelHardmantestimony.pdf


Star Teacher Online Pre-Screener and Star Urban Administrator Online Questionnaire
Haberman Educational Foundation Inc, Houston, Texas.

Called ‘The Star Teacher Interview,’ the Star Teacher Online Pre-Screener boasts a 95% accuracy rate in predicting which teachers will stay and succeed and which ones will fail or quit.  High success rates result from the ability of the scenario-based interview to give a clear picture of the candidate's beliefs about teaching at risk youth, and to predict how a candidate will behave on the job; which ones will be able to handle the stress, the discipline, the unmotivated students, those who learn differently. . . . The Star Urban Administrator Online Questionnaire predicts which candidates will succeed as school principals serving diverse children and youth in urban poverty in major urban school districts. It analyzes respondents' answers to thirteen dimensions of urban school administration.  These dimensions were identified in . . . studies of Star urban principals who led effective schools in major urban districts or who turned failing schools into effective ones.”.
Star Teacher Online Pre-Screener: For purchase.
http://www.altcert.org/StarTeacherPreScreener.aspx
Star Teacher Urban Administrator Online Questionnaire: For purchase.
http://www.altcert.org/StarAdministratorQuestionnaire.aspx


Teacher Compensation Papers
Strategic Management of Human Capital (SMHC)
University of Wisconsin-Madison. (2008).
A Consortium for Policy Research in Education (CPRE) Project.

“Through a Task Force, this Web site, an annual conference, case studies and a National Reform Network, the SMHC action project will share and implement nationwide effective practices to recruit, train, retain and reward top teacher and school administrator talent.”  Five papers on teacher compensation are available: (a) New Teacher Pay Structures: The Compensation Side of the Strategic Management of Human Capital, by Allan Odden; (b) Do Teacher Pay Levels Matter?, by Adam Milanowski; (c) How to Design New Teacher Salary Structures, by Herbert C. Henemann III and Steve Kimball; (d) How to Pay Teachers for Student Performance Outcomes, by Anthony Milanowski; and (e) How to Fund Teacher Compensation Changes, by Allan Odden.
Full texts – Scroll down:
http://www.smhc-cpre.org/resources/


Teacher Quality and Dropout Outcomes in a Large, Urban School District
National Center on Performance Incentives,
Vanderbilt University, Nashville, Tennessee. (2007).  C. Koedel.

“Recent research shows that variation in teacher quality has large effects on student performance.  However, this research is based entirely on student test scores.  This paper evaluates teacher quality in terms of another educational outcome of great interest -- graduation.  Using a unique instrumental variables approach to identify teacher effects, the author found that differences in teacher quality have large effects on graduation outcomes.  Because teacher effects on graduation outcomes will be more pronounced for students who are on the graduation margin, the results imply an avenue through which high-quality teachers are more productive with disadvantaged students.”
Full text:
http://www.performanceincentives.org/news__events/detail.asp?pageaction=
ViewSinglePublic&LinkID=159&ModuleID=25&NEWSPID=1



Teacher Quality and Student Achievement:  Research Review
Center for Public Education, An Initiative of the National School Boards Association and the National School Boards Foundation, Washington DC. (2005).

“The importance of good teachers is no secret. Schools and their communities have always sought out the best teachers they could get in the belief that their students’ success depends on it.   But what we know instinctively still leaves some big questions, especially for those in charge of hiring, training and retaining a qualified teaching force. To begin with, how do you define a good teacher? What characteristics do you look for? Given all the factors related to student performance, how much impact can we expect from teachers? And finally, if teachers are so important to student learning, how can we make sure all students receive the benefit of good teachers?  In this overview, the Center looks at research that seeks to answer these questions.”
Full text:
http://www.centerforpubliceducation.org/site/apps/nl/content2.asp?c=kjJXJ5MPIwE&b=1498577&ct=2040135
Rubric for evaluating research:
http://www.centerforpubliceducation.org/site/c.kjJXJ5MPIwE/b.1518283/k.8F43/
Center_for_Public_Educations_rubric_for_evaluating_research.htm



Teacher Quality Research (TQR)
A Partnership Between Researchers at Florida State University, Tallahassee,
and the University of Wisconsin-Madison

“The purpose of TQR is to provide research evidence on the characteristics and education of effective teachers, in order to develop policies to improve the quality of teachers and instruction.  Researchers address the following basic questions about teacher quality: (a) What is the best way to measure each teacher’s contribution to student achievement — their ‘value-added’?, (b) What teacher characteristics are associated with higher teacher value-added?, (c) Are teachers with high value-added also considered effective according to other measures?, and (d) What does research mean – and not mean – for policies aimed at improving the quality of teaching.”   Several papers are available.
Home page – Click at the left for research publications:
http://www.teacherqualityresearch.org/


Teaching Inequality:
How Poor and Minority Students Are Shortchanged on Teacher Quality

The Education Trust, Washington DC. (2006).  H. G. Peske & K. Haycock
Distributed by the Math Science Partnerships Learning Network (MSPNet)

"In 2004, Ohio, Illinois, and Wisconsin and their largest school systems (Cleveland, Chicago, and Milwaukee) joined with the Education Trust to work on teacher distribution.    Together, teams of stakeholders in each jurisdiction collected data on teacher distribution and  identified patterns.  In every case, they found large differences  between the qualifications of teachers in the highest-poverty  and highest-minority schools and teachers serving in schools  with few minority and low-income students.  The teams then analyzed the information to determine possible reasons for the patterns, and came up with strategies to achieve a fairer  distribution. This report draws from their experiences in an effort to help other States and cities as they prepare their  own action plans. The report: (a) describes teacher distribution patterns nationally, along with selected findings in these pilot States and districts; (b) summarizes evidence about how differences in teacher quality affect student achievement, especially among low-income students, students of color, and low-achieving students of all races; (c) explains the requirement in No Child Left Behind that all groups of children receive their fair share of strong teachers; (d) shares key lessons from the pilot States and districts that may be useful to other States and districts as they move to address the problem of teacher distribution; and (e) sets forth a range of strategies that can be used to address this problem — some from the stakeholder groups in the pilot states and districts, and others from the Education Trust.”
Full text: http://hub.mspnet.org/index.cfm/13140


The Impact of Mentoring on Teacher Retention:  What the Research Says
Education Commission of the States, Denver, Colorado. (2004).
R. Ingersoll & J. M. Kralik.

“This report’s primary objective is to provide policymakers, educators and researchers with a reliable assessment of what is known, and not known, about the effectiveness – the value added – of teacher induction programs.  In particular, this review focuses on the impact of induction and mentoring programs on teacher retention. . . . While the literature search located some 150 empirical studies of induction and mentoring programs, in the end only 10 studies could be included for this ECS review because all studies had to satisfy three criteria (qualitative data; evaluation and outcomes; and comparisons). . . . While the impact of induction and mentoring differed significantly among the 10 studies reviewed, collectively the studies do provide empirical support for the claim that assistance for new teachers and, in particular, mentoring programs have a positive impact on teachers and their retention.”
Full text:    http://www.ecs.org/clearinghouse/50/36/5036.htm


Tips and Tools:  Emerging Strategies to Enhance Educator Quality
National Comprehensive Center for Teacher Quality, Washington DC.

This page offers strategies for improving teacher and leadership quality.  Currently, this collection covers  (a) identifying and supporting highly effective teachers; (b) enhancing leadership quality; (c) improving teacher quality through the implementation of a multi-tiered intervention system; (d) recruiting quality teachers for mathematics, science, and special education; and (e) improving teacher quality in at-risk schools.
Emerging strategies:
http://www.tqsource.org/strategies/


Too Angry to Leave:
Supporting New Teachers’ Commitment to Transform Urban Schools

Institute for Democracy, Education, and Access, University of California,
Los Angeles. (2005).  K. H. Quartz and TEP Research Group.

“This paper reports research on one effort to curb urban teacher attrition through a non-traditional approach to urban teacher education, induction and ongoing professional development.  It combines quantitative data about the retention rates over five years of teachers prepared specifically as ‘social justice’ urban educators with qualitative data about the type of preparation and ongoing support that the teachers experienced.  Analyses of these data enable the authors to suggest and probe those elements of preparation and support that may be efficacious in remedying ‘the revolving door’ of urban schools.  This single case study attempts to extend the broad literature on teacher retention while establishing some groundwork for further investigations of urban teachers’ learning and career paths. The paper concludes with a proposal to reframe the professionalization of teaching debate to fit the realities of urban schools.”
Full text:   http://idea.gseis.ucla.edu/publications/utec/reports/rrs06.html


Understanding New York City’s Groundbreaking Induction Initiative:
Policy Implications for Local, State, and National Education Leaders

New Teacher Center, University of California, Santa Cruz. (2006).

”In August of 2004, New York City launched possibly the largest, most aggressive overhaul of teacher induction in the country.  Recognizing . . . that many new teachers were leaving the city schools faster than they could be replaced, the NYC Department of Education, the United Federation of Teachers, and the New Teacher Center at the University of California, Santa Cruz, joined forces to implement a $36 million program that would change the way new teachers are supported throughout the city.  The goals of the program were not only to stem the high attrition rates of new teachers, but also to build a culture of learning that builds upon the knowledge and skills of the systems most accomplished educators and transforms isolated teaching experiences into rich opportunities for collaboration. . . . This report provides the first insights into the successes and challenges of program implementation, reviews the effectiveness of various aspects of the program’s design, and articulates policy implications for local, State, and national induction policy efforts.”
Executive summary and full text – Scroll to the second title:
http://www.newteachercenter.org/nyc_policy_paper.php


Urban Teacher Retention Policy: A Research Brief
Institute for Democracy, Education, and Access, University of California,
Los Angeles. (2004).  K. H. Quartz, K. B. Lyons, K. Masyn, B. Olsen, L. Anderson,
A. Thomas,  J. Goode, & E. L. Horng.

“This research brief summarizes interim results from a longitudinal study designed to inform policies aimed at curbing the high rate of attrition from hard-to-staff urban schools. These policies range from ensuring specialized teacher preservice education that will prepare teachers for the challenges ahead -- to ongoing support for professional development and advancement.”
Full text:  http://idea.gseis.ucla.edu/publications/utec/wp/02.html


What Keeps Good Teachers in the Classroom? 
Understanding and Reducing Teacher Turnover

Alliance for Excellent Education, Washington DC. (2008).

This Issue Brief  reviews reasons that teachers leave the profession, and concludes that “ certainly, a teacher’s decision to stay or leave a particular school is contingent on a variety of factors — ranging from teachers’ personal characteristics to their satisfaction with the school’s environment.  However, in all cases, the key seems to lie in the level of success teachers encounter in raising their students’ academic performances.  For this reason, giving teachers the supports necessary to succeed is critical.  Policy changes and systemwide improvement efforts should focus on making such success possible. New teachers, in particular, are at risk of leaving the profession within their first year of teaching if they are unprepared and unsupported to teach in challenging situations.”  The remainder of the paper makes the case for comprehensive induction programs that include ”varying degrees of training, support, and assessment during a teacher’s first year on the job.”
Press release – Click at the bottom for the full text:
http://www.all4ed.org/press_room/press_releases/02262008



Return to main menu: Achievement Gaps, Diversity, and Disproportionality
http://www.rrfcnetwork.org/content/view/195/47/

   


This information is an attempt to gather wide-ranging information in one place, to convey what others have accomplished, and to make valuable resources readily accessible.  Information is presented in the language of the developer, publisher, distributor, or author.  The Southeast Regional Resource Center has no ownership of anything described in this library.

Readers should review the copyright and distribution policies shown at the websites of the sources.  SERRC is not the source of any document in this library, but simply conveys information to show the availability of these resources.

 The opinions expressed herein do not necessarily reflect the position of policy of the U.S. Department of Education, and no endorsement of the U.S. Department of Education should be inferred.  Information from sources funded by the U.S. Department of Education is likely to have been vetted by the Department; information from other sources is unlikely to have been vetted.







Last Updated ( Tuesday, 09 December 2008 )

SERRC Menu
Copyright 2008. All rights reserved.