|
|
|
Culturally Responsive Research |
|
|
Culturally Responsive Research and Evaluation: Reports/Recommendations, Resources, and Guides Updated in October 2008
ADDED IN OCTOBER
Interrogating Classroom Relationships and Events -- Using Portraiture and Critical Race Theory in Education Research .
Titles are presented in alphabetical order
Alaska Federation of Natives: Guidelines for Research Alaska Federation of Natives, Fairbanks, Alaska.
“The Alaska Federation of Natives’ Board of Directors adopted a policy recommendation (in the 1990s) that includes a set of research principles to be conveyed to scientists who plan to conduct studies among Alaska Natives. . . . The best scientific and ethical standards are obtained when Alaska Natives are directly involved in research conducted in our communities and in studies where the findings have a direct impact on Native populations.” The Guidelines: http://www.ankn.uaf.edu/IKS/afnguide.html
Can Experimental Research Be Conducted with Culturally Based Education Interventions? An Assessment of Feasibility Presentation at the 2005 Annual Conference of the American Educational Research Association in Montreal. K. O. Yap, W. G. Demmert, D. Beaulieu, R. G. Tharp, J. C. Towner, & J. Kushman. Distributed by the Northwest Regional Educational Laboratory.
This study “was conducted to assess the feasibility of conducting experimental research with culturally based education (CBE) interventions. The assessment was made on the basis of a comprehensive review of the relevant literature on culturally based education and a national survey with a sample of 105 CBE programs in 21 states. The literature review shows that much of the extant research on CBE is descriptive. Only six studies use some form of randomized assignment of students to treatment and control conditions. In the national survey, a sizeable number of school administrators indicate that it is feasible to investigate the efficacy of CBE interventions using experimental or quasi-experimental designs. Results of this preliminary study clearly show that CBE is not a unitary concept. It is an eclectic collection of treatments tailored to meet the needs of particular Native student populations in a local school context. To test the efficacy of CBE interventions, the paper proposes the use of a combination of research designs.” Full text -- Scroll down: http://www.nwrel.org/aera05/
Celebrating Diversity and Denying Disparities: A Critical Assessment. Educational Researcher. (2004). American Educational Research Association, S. T. Lubienski.
“In the past, researchers concerned with educational achievement gaps sought to identify underlying causes of those gaps by examining deficiencies of students’ home backgrounds. In reaction against this ‘blame the victim’ approach, scholars have moved toward focusing on positive aspects of diversity. This article raises critical questions about the tradeoffs of framing all diversity as positive. The author contends that such framings divert attention from socioeconomic diversity and obscure larger, structural inequities. Moreover, by avoiding the difficult issues that many marginalized parents, students, and their teachers face daily, educational research risks becoming less useful and credible.” Abstract (full text for purchase): http://edr.sagepub.com/cgi/content/abstract/32/8/30 Culturally Competent Evaluation for Aboriginal Communities: A Review of the Empirical LiteratureJournal of Multidisciplinary Evaluation. (2007). Western Michigan University, Kalamazoo. J. A. Chouinard & J. B. Cousins. “The purpose of this paper is to review and synthesize the current empirical literature on cross-cultural evaluation in Aboriginal communities, and to begin to address the recognized lack of critically engaged discussion about research on culturally competent evaluation. . . . To provide focus for this review (the authors) posed the following key questions: (a) What is culturally competent evaluation; what are the benefits to such practices; why bother; why does culture matter?; (b) What does a culturally competent evaluation in Aboriginal communities look like; what are the relevant findings? what are the relevant findings?; (c) What methodological practices have been found to be culturally relevant in Aboriginal communities? what evaluation approaches? And (d) What is missing in the literature; what gaps remain to be addressed?” Full Text – Under Articles:http://survey.ate.wmich.edu/jmde/index.php/jmde_1/issue/view/24Culturally Sensitive Research Approaches: An African American PerspectiveEducational Researcher. (2002). American Educational Research Association. L. C. Tillman. “This article contributes to discussions about culturally sensitive research approaches in qualitative research. The author argues that the use of culturally sensitive research approaches in research focusing on African Americans can use the cultural knowledge and experiences of researchers and their participants in the design of the research as well as in the collection and interpretation of data. The author presents a rationale for the use of culturally sensitive research approaches for African Americans, a theoretical framework for culturally sensitive research approaches, and a discussion of culturally sensitive research in practice. The article concludes by discussing some implications for teaching and practice in educational research.” Full Text--Under Features: http://www.aera.net/publications/?id=439
Diverse Voices: Inclusion of Language-Minority Populations in National Studies
National Institute of Child Health and Human Development (NICHD), National Institutes of Health. (2001). “In July 2001, the NICHD held a workshop, with funding assistance from the NIH Office of Research on Minority Health, on the inclusion of language-minority populations in national studies. This 44-page scientific report describes the workshop and the topics discussed, including (a) describing language-minority populations; (b) challenges for including these populations in surveys; (c) sampling, measuring, and interviewing these populations; and (d) technological innovations and linguistic logistics.” Full text:http://www.nichd.nih.gov/publications/pubs_details.cfm?from=&pubs_id=230
Handbook of Research on Multicultural Education, Second Edition Jossey-Bass/A. Wiley Company, San Francisco, California. (2003). J. A. Banks, Editor, & C. A. McGee Banks, Associate Editor
“The Handbook brings together in one volume the major research and scholarship related to multicultural education that has developed since the field emerged in the 1960s and 1970s. Research is broadly defined in this handbook. It includes discussions and summaries of research using experimental and quasi-experimental designs, historical and philosophical inquiry, ethnographic studies, survey research, scholarship broadly defined, and insights gained from practice. Each chapter, which is written by a leading authority, critically discusses and summarizes the research on a specific topic, as well as describe the implications of the discussion for further research, policy, and practice.” Overview: http://depts.washington.edu/centerme/2ndhand.htm For purchase: http://www.josseybass.com/WileyCDA/WileyTitle/productCd-0787959154.html
Implementing Culturally Competent Research Practices: Identifying Strengths of African-American Communities, Families, and Children Focal Point. (2003). Research and Training Center on Family Support and Children’s Mental Health, University of Portland, Oregon. R. S.Briscoe & G. McClain.
“This article focuses on the methods and results of two research projects aimed at identifying strengths in African-American families and communities. The studies provided a strong foundation for identifying and supporting the development of a strengths-based approach with African-American children, families and communities.” Full text – Scroll down: http://www.rtc.pdx.edu/pgFPS03TOC.php
Innovations in Educational Ethnography: Theories, Methods, and Results
Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Inc, Mahwah, New Jersey. (2006). G. Spidler & L. Hammond (Eds.). “This volume focuses on and exemplifies how ethnography -- a research tool devoted to looking at human interaction as a cultural process rather than individual psychology--can shed light on educational processes framed by the complex, internationalized societies in which we live today. Part I offers theoretical chapters about ethnography and examples of innovative ethnography from particular perspectives. In Part II, the emphasis is on the application of ethnographic approaches to educational settings.” For purchase: http://www.amazon.com/Innovations-Educational-Ethnography-Theories-Methods/dp/0805845313
Intensive Qualitative Research: Challenges, Best Uses, and Opportunities
MDRC, New York City. (2003). A. Gardenhire & L. Nelson. “This paper is the first in MDRC's series on research methodology to examine the use of ethnographic interviews, focus groups, and other intensive qualitative methods in social policy research. . . . It highlights the unique contributions that qualitative methods can make to efforts to understand the effects of social programs and discusses the challenges of integrating qualitative research into the design, analysis, and presentation of social policy evaluations. (The paper) culminates in specific guidelines for getting the most out of qualitative methods.” The research examples described in this paper include examination of the effects of (a) increasing self-sufficiency of teenage, welfare-dependent mothers who had dropped out of high school; (b) employment supports for low-income, non-custodial parents; (c) income supplements for low-income individuals; and (d) welfare reform legislation on low-income communities and families in four large, urban counties. Abstract and click for full text:http://www.mdrc.org/publications/339/abstract.html Interrogating Classroom Relationships and Events: Using Portraiture and Critical Race Theory in Education ResearchEducational Researcher (2007). American Educational Research Association. T. K. Chapman. “This article explores the use of the methodology of portraiture and the analytic framework of critical race theory (CRT) to evaluate success and failure in urban classrooms. Portraiture and CRT share a number of features that make the two a viable pair for conducting research in urban schools. In combination, portraiture and CRT allow researchers to evoke the personal, the professional, and the political to illuminate issues of race, class, and gender in education research and to create possibilities for urban school reform as social action.” Full Text – Under Research and Comment:http://www.aera.net/publications/Default.aspx?menu_id=38&id=2904
Ka‘aka–lai Ku–Kanaka: A Call for Strengths-Based Approaches from a Native Hawaiian Perspective Educational Researcher. (2005). American Educational Research Association. S. M. Kana'iaupuni.
The author underscores “the compelling need for research about Native Hawai’ians based on strengths, rather than deficits, and from a Native Hawai’ian worldview. This call echoes mounting scholarship insisting on indigenous perspectives in research and action. . . . (The article ends) by calling for a new framework that brings to the fore Native Hawai’ian strengths that have been too long misinterpreted, misrecognized, and undervalued.” Full text – Under Research News and Comment: http://www.aera.net/publications/?id=771
Reassessing the Role of Ethnographic Methods in Education Policy Research: Implementing Bilingual Education Policy at Local Levels
Teachers College Record, Columbia University Teachers College, New York City. (2006). T. T. Stritkus & A-M. Wiese. “In this article, (the authors) address the ongoing call for research to be more relevant to educational policy and practice by focusing on the public controversy regarding bilingual education. To show how ethnographic research can be relevant, (they) present findings of two independent but parallel studies of how teachers implement bilingual education policies based on Proposition 227 in California. Findings from both studies indicate that the use of ethnographic methods yields a rich account of various factors that play a crucial role in determining how educational policy is implemented. In reporting on these ethnographic studies, (the authors) seek to provide an alternative voice in the ongoing discussion about the role of research in educational policy and practice.” Abstract (Full text by membership or purchase):http://www.tcrecord.org/Content.asp?ContentID=12519
Reconceptualizing Race and Ethnicity in Educational Research: Theme Issue
Educational Researcher. (June/July 2003). American Educational Research Association. This theme issue on cultural concepts and methodologies in research includes an editor’s introduction, four full-length articles, and a book review on the topic of race and ethnicity in research. Full text of entire theme issue:http://www.aera.net/publications/?id=397
Research Reconsiderations Concerning Cultural DifferencesContemporary Issues in Early Childhood. (2004). Symposium Journals, United Kingdom. A. A, Becher. “Critical multiculturalism raises the question of cultural differences and of how to theorize and do research without creating culturally essentializing categories. This article alerts readers to the plight of children in shifting cultural contexts, to the challenges they are facing, and to the skills and competencies they are developing. It seeks to contribute to two current areas of debate, namely inclusive education and internationalization.” Abstract and click for the full text: http://www.wwwords.co.uk/ciec/content/pdfs/5/issue5_1.asp#7
Studying Across Race: A Conversation About the Place of Difference in Qualitative Research
Contemporary Issues in Early Childhood (2005). Symposium Journals, Oxford, United Kingdom. G. Barclay-McLaughlin & J. A. Hatch “This article is a dialog between colleagues from different races who struggle with the complexities of doing qualitative research with participants who come from backgrounds that do not match their own. Based on transcriptions of extensive audiotaped conversations, the article explores issues related to studying across difference. The discussion is framed by four qualitative research paradigms: post-positivist, constructivist, critical/feminist, and poststructuralist.” Full Text: http://www.wwwords.co.uk/ciec/content/pdfs/6/issue6_3.asp#1
Ten Strategies for Enhancing Multicultural Competency in Evaluation.
Using Culturally Sensitive Methodologies When Researching Diverse Cultures. Journal of Multidisciplinary Evaluation. (2006). The Evaluation Center, Western Michigan University. E. J. Baugh & L. Guion.
“The purpose of this article is to introduce additional information in the ongoing conversation about using culturally sensitive research methods with diverse research populations. Research, including evaluation research, examining ethnic minorities, international, tribal members, and individuals within diverse cultures should be performed within a context of cultural understanding. Several methodological examples will be presented, expanding the discussion of contemporary research with diverse cultures.” Full text – First title under Articles: http://survey.ate.wmich.edu/jmde/index.php/jmde_1/issue/view/16
Return to main menu: Achievement Gaps, Diversity, and Disproportionality http://www.rrfcnetwork.org/content/view/195/47/
This information is an attempt to gather wide-ranging information in one place, to convey what others have accomplished, and to make valuable resources readily accessible. Information is presented in the language of the developer, publisher, distributor, or author. The Southeast Regional Resource Center has no ownership of anything described in this library.
Readers should review the copyright and distribution policies shown at the websites of the sources. SERRC is not the source of any document in this library, but simply conveys information to show the availability of these resources.
The opinions expressed herein do not necessarily reflect the position of policy of the U.S. Department of Education, and no endorsement of the U.S. Department of Education should be inferred. Information from sources funded by the U.S. Department of Education is likely to have been vetted by the Department; information from other sources is unlikely to have been vetted.
|
|
Last Updated ( Tuesday, 07 October 2008 )
|
|
|